---
title: "Maester v4.6 Live Apply Session 결과 보고"
from: codex
to: ["jadong", "claude-code"]
project: "maester"
date: 2026-05-09T14:14:55.053276+09:00
status: sent
type: result
---

# Maester v4.6 Live Apply Session 결과 보고

## 핵심 요약

- v4.6 Live Apply Session 완료
- 실제 적용은 승인 파일 부재로 실행하지 않음
- 승인 템플릿 8건 생성
- eval 전부 PASS
- Tiro auto-ingest OFF 유지
- 다음 단계: operator가 승인할 명령을 `data/operator_approved_commands.jsonl`로 확정

---

# Maester v4.6 Live Apply Session Report

## Summary

- generated_at: 2026-05-09T03:29:40.675257+00:00
- Business Eval baseline: GOOD 10/10
- approval_file_exists: False
- template_count: 8
- apply_phase: SKIPPED_NO_APPROVAL_FILE
- live apply eval all pass: True
- suggested commands: 8
- API runtime: ok=True, pid=2288895, unit=maester-api.service, runtime_code_hash=3f24e07dd4f52b5c

## Eval Checks

- approval_template_created: PASS
- approval_file_absent_or_valid: PASS
- no_apply_without_approval: PASS
- dry_runs_all_pass: PASS
- tiro_auto_ingest_off: PASS

## Approval Template

- template: `data/operator_approved_commands.template.jsonl`
- approval target: `data/operator_approved_commands.jsonl`

## Artifacts

- `/tmp/maester_v4_6_approval_template.md`
- `/tmp/maester_v4_6_live_apply_eval.md`
- `/tmp/maester_v4_6_live_apply_report.md`
- `data/operator_approved_commands.template.jsonl`
- `HANDOFF_v4.7.md`


---

# Maester v4.6 Live Apply Eval

## Success Checks

- approval_template_created: PASS
- approval_file_absent_or_valid: PASS
- no_apply_without_approval: PASS
- dry_runs_all_pass: PASS
- tiro_auto_ingest_off: PASS

## Metrics

- approval_file_exists: False
- template_count: 8
- apply_phase: SKIPPED_NO_APPROVAL_FILE
- dry_run_count: 8


---

# Maester v4.6 Approval Template

- approval_path: `data/operator_approved_commands.jsonl`
- approval_file_exists: False
- template_path: `data/operator_approved_commands.template.jsonl`
- apply_phase: PENDING_APPROVAL_FILE

Copy selected lines into `data/operator_approved_commands.jsonl` to approve real apply.

```jsonl
{"short_id": "O01", "command": "carry-forward", "due": "2026-05-10", "reason": "overdue 2026-05-08 -> operator can carry forward", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_O01_carry_forward_preview"}
{"short_id": "O02", "command": "carry-forward", "due": "2026-05-10", "reason": "overdue 2026-05-08 -> operator can carry forward", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_O02_carry_forward_preview"}
{"short_id": "A01", "command": "done", "outcome": "브랜드콘텐츠 원고 완성 후 파워컨텐츠 등록 결과를 여기에 적기", "reason": "등록 화면에 넣을 제목/본문/키워드/URL이 확정되어야 한다.", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_A01_done_preview"}
{"short_id": "A02", "command": "done", "outcome": "캡스 계약서 작성 요청 결과를 여기에 적기", "reason": "요청 또는 제출이 완료되고 다음 대기 대상이 명확해진다.", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_A02_done_preview"}
{"short_id": "A03", "command": "waiting", "waiting_on": "김경필 실장 회신", "reason": "토스 후속은 회신 대기 상태로 전환할 수 있음", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_A03_waiting_preview"}
{"short_id": "T01", "command": "approve", "reason": "Tiro queue 승인 후보. apply해도 ingest는 하지 않음.", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_T01_approve_preview"}
{"short_id": "T02", "command": "approve", "reason": "Tiro queue 승인 후보. apply해도 ingest는 하지 않음.", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_T02_approve_preview"}
{"short_id": "T03", "command": "approve", "reason": "Tiro queue 승인 후보. apply해도 ingest는 하지 않음.", "apply": true, "idempotency_key": "v4_5_2026-05-09_T03_approve_preview"}
```


---

# HANDOFF v4.7 — Maester v4.6 Live Apply Session

## State

- Approval file exists: False
- Apply phase: SKIPPED_NO_APPROVAL_FILE
- Template rows: 8
- Eval all pass: True

## Implemented

- Approval template generated at `data/operator_approved_commands.template.jsonl`.
- Real apply remains blocked because `data/operator_approved_commands.jsonl` is absent.
- Dry-run matrix remains passing.
- No real business command was applied in v4.6.

## Operator Next Step

- Copy selected template lines into `data/operator_approved_commands.jsonl`.
- Keep `apply:true` and `idempotency_key` on each approved line.
- Re-run `scripts/apply_operator_approved_commands_v4_5.py` or the next live apply loop.